H!P Retro Review #4, Berryz!

Comments

This your best retro review yet. It was easy to see at this point that Berryz had superstar potential, which they have realized in a big way. You mention the Maiha and Saitama concerts ... in those two and this one, the major drawback I see is: Costumes! Why is it that Berryz always gets the raw end on outfits compared to, say, C-ute or Morning Musume? Berryz' outfits are ridiculously ugly for the most part and it takes away from the talent of this group.

The songs are cutting edge, all of them. The "sexiness" aspect is something I try and keep separate from the artistry I'm seeing and hearing, but such an element is what keeps these kinds of groups alive, so it is a necessary evil, moreson for C-ute and Morning Musume than Berryz.

I would be slow to criticize Risako vocally, because after this concert her stock began to rise; Very Beauty, and the solo she did in the Saitama concert, etc. Plus, the year before, in the Maiha graduation concert, I thought Risako was sensational, head and shoulders above anyone else in that group for that perf, a historic effort. It was obvious she took Maiha's leaving very hard, and that edge leaked into the show, for the good of all who have a copy of that DVD.

Oops! forget one thing. The feed of Risako seen on YouTube is the raw tone that gets driven through the sound system, amplified and enhanced significantly. All the girls would have a similar raw sound, even Miyabi and Momoko. Yes, the singers are singing, but the tone is pumped up brutally, and the background vocals/track are also folded in. It's not entirely live, yes, but no doubt Risako's voice was used in that example, mixed with the other six members plus a large doze of digital dazzle.

Got it, makes me want to watch "Switch On" again. I, for one, don't hate Risako. And like when people call Kei-chan "ugly", it pains me to hear people call Risako ugly names as well. She's not even in high school yet, for cripes sake!!! As for this show, I'm just callin' it as I see it. And Risako and Yurina were serious vocal liabilities at this point.

As far as "sexiness" is concerned, I just feel none of these girls are old enough to be considered that way. At least by an adult. Don't get me wrong, I think they're adorable! It's just a morality thing.

Thanks for the encouraging words.

P.S.: I think you'll like the screencap collection I've assembled on the Bomb Girl concert -- especially the captions!

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in