Hello! Project Retro Review #1

Comments

"Unmei" is a hell of a song and was a killer in the 2005 show. Yeah, yeah, it's just a simple song, but when the crowd echoed Miki and the others on "Do You Love Me?" four times over, that was too much of a good thing for me! The junior groups Berryz and C-ute (which was just barely C-ute at that time) really started to take off. Great, great concert in H!P history; great observations, Chris.

http://www.bloggerparty.com/blog/radreview

Oh, I really love this concert! I only watched it a couple of days ago and when I now read this all the funny moments came to my mind. :) I wonder why they dropped that choir song thing they did in all the old H!P concerts. I would love to see them in recent concerts also, with the enormous amount of members H!P has nowadays... If all eggs participated that would be one hell of a choir. :)

I must admit that Country Musume is in my opinion also the cutest group ever, though I love Rinne instead of Asami. Country Musume really did have that "the plain country girl (next door)" feeling. The best performances besides that were Mikitty's (I love Let's Do Dai Hakken!), Minimoni's (Hinamatsuri is like my favourite song from them :P) and Heike Michiyo's. I only discovered that I love her music some time ago and Propose is my favourite! But I think she looked a bit too skinny...

As for Ayaya: even though I really enjoy old Ayaya songs when I listen to then from CDs and I definitely do not deny that she is a tremendous performer, for some mysterious reason I never seem to enjoy her live performances that much. I have no idea why - I love her songs and in GAM her live performances definitely interested me. I don't know. Maybe the fact that she gets a little tired with her singing (which is not odd at all as her dance routines are just as energetic as Momusu's but she has to sing all the lines by herself) irritates me. But anyway, she's great too.

I loved it too, it's what inspired me to start this series. Most of these older concerts I'm seeing in their entirety for the first time, now that I have a DVD player that plays them. I agree that these special moments would be great on the newer shows. As much as I loved the concert in Yokohama, it was a "cookie cutter" set list. Big opening, then all the latest releases, an elders club hodgepodge, Morning Musume, and a big finish. Run of the mill, and I loved every minute of it.

Rinne runs a close second to me in Country Musume. One of my DVD's has a great rendition of Hokkaido Shalala with her on guitar.

I'm stalling an Ayaya concert review, as it is all her. So it's tougher to make the composition interesting. I'll figure it our. Thanks for the comments! Back to watching Bonkyu Bomb! (came in the mail today)

I remember that concert where Rinne sings Hokkaido Shalala. It was a Momusu concert, wasn't it? I think that that early H!P concert were never released on DVD which is a shame. But the guitar playing... I was having a hard time trying to figure out if she really knew how to play guitar or not. At least she wasn't really playing it in the concert, the guitar didn't even have a mike (as far as I remember, but I could remember wrong :P). But as she plays guitar also in Koi ga Suteki na Kisetsu PV as well as in Hokkaidou Shalala PV, so maybe she does know... It just didn't really look like it.

I'm really looking forward to your Ayaya concert review, because to my shame I have to admit that I've never watched one. Maybe it'll give me some insipiration to watch Ayaya's concerts.

The version I am thinking of is from First Live at Budokan. I'm pretty sure she knows how to play the guitar, at one point she is fingering a basic "C" chord. But I agree it probably wasn't mic'd. And she doesn't get a musician credit on the CD either. I'm still deciding on which Ayaya concert to review first. I have two so far, 2002 First Date, and Live in Shanghai 2006. I'll figure it out!

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in